
Writer/director Michael Dougherty is one of the writers behind Superman Returns and X2, which led me to believe this movie was going to suck. Not because those are terrible movies, but because the type of mind capable of engineering crowd pleasers usually doesn’t know jack shit about horror. (See: When Michael Bay got a wild urge to produce a Texas Chainsaw Massacre remake, a movie I can’t imagine he ever actually watched, let alone liked.) Doughtery is an exception to the rule. Though Trick ‘r Treat looks like an expensive studio film, it doesn’t behave like one.
Nor does it look like a studio film from the 2000s. Consider what the average overproduced horror movie looked like at the time. Everything had an artificial slickness to it, greatly in part due to the recent advancement of digital color correction. Phony looking CGI was used out the wazoo, often to rob a practical effect of its punch. And it was the golden age of endless remakes, PG-13 ratings, and horror as tame as daytime television. Doughtery bucks the trends, making instead a film that’s equal parts whimsical and gruesome. There’s only one brief shot I clocked as gratuitous CGI. Luckily, it didn’t take me completely out of the movie. (I have a feeling CGI is used all over the place, but if it’s tasteful enough that I don’t notice it, who gives a shit?)
Told out of chronological order, the film cold-opens with a tasteful nod to John Carpenter’s Halloween before careening into a dark comedy featuring the wonderful pairing of Dylan Baker and Brett Kelly, the latter of whom played Thurman Merman in Bad Santa. This segment introduces the premise of the film: Halloween was a tradition designed to keep the bad things at bay, but because nobody takes the holiday seriously anymore, the bad things are slowly creeping back into the world. There are a lot of bad things in Dougherty’s world, from killer bus drivers to vampires who feel emboldened enough to kill in the middle of a crowded street.

One tale has Anna Paquin walking a wooded trail in a Little Red Riding Hood costume. Another features Brian Cox wearing a prosthetic nose that makes him appear as if he’s auditioning for Ebenezer Scrooge. Perhaps my favorite tale of all reveals why a group of local kids are collecting a specific number of jack-o-lanterns; there’s a tale within the tale, which is told in the manner of a creepy campfire story, sans campfire. The most interesting of all the creatures is the small figure which is seen appearing across every section of the movie, always watching from the shadows with a large burlap mask and a candy bag. This little bugger becomes considerably less interesting when it is ultimately unmasked, but I respect what Dougherty was going for here.
I was beginning to believe I had already seen every great horror anthology film. Trick ‘r Treat proves me wrong. The genius of it is the fact that not only are all these tales interconnected in amusing ways, Dougherty chews them up and spits them out into a traditional narrative rather than giving them the segmented pace that derails too many anthologies. Frankly, I don’t even know how it occurred to him to skip a horror host or a container gimmick. It kind of makes everything preceding it feel old hat. Most impressive of all is the fact that all the tales are equally entertaining. No duds. No bullshit. Just an extremely entertaining movie.





















